Headlines

LETTERS: Having Reservist NSmen Fix Specialised War Machines Is a Disaster-in-the-Making

redwire-singapore-army-x824

KENG LUN: The Aloysius Pang training mishap has raised a bigger issue which I’m sure all of us national servicemen are wondering about, which is whether reservist NSmen should be made to do tasks which require specialised skills such as machine repairs. While I have no doubt reservist will always do their best when necessary, there is a limit to the depth of their abilities when it comes to war machines.

We are called “Operationally-Ready”, but the fact is for those who don’t use these skills in our daily lives, those skills become rusty and forgotten. We are talking about specialised machines which are complex to operate, not simple tools like bicycles or semi-automatic rifles. Would you trust the repair of a multi-million-dollar F-35 jet plane to a NSman whose day job is selling insurance, or whatever else occupation that doesn’t involve fixing planes?

A once-a-year brief refresher course is not going to make anyone an expert. As it is stands, some reservist even need time to figure out how to use a SAR-21. Skills to operate or repair complex machines should naturally involve experts who can be relied on to intuitively devise solutions when things go wrong, and fix things taking with thorough understanding of how the machines work.

When machines fail and people fail, mishaps that bring injury or death often follow. MINDEF must rethink its strategies for troop deployment, and let reservists perform more general tasks which can be easily relearned every year during ICT.

In war, friendly-fire is estimated to account for up to 20 percent of battlefield casualties. Let’s not add “friendly-error” to the mix.

 

 

3 Comments

3 Comments

  1. Anonymous

    January 25, 2019 at 9:13 pm

    All t govt n govt-connected hospitals shd have an easy route for patients to seek a second opinion at another hospital. To let t patient know there may be simpler less costly options. True, it is like comparing apples n oranges but we must help the patient understand. Most patients hv limited resources.

  2. John

    January 25, 2019 at 10:27 pm

    I think your example of a F35 is not suitable here. Please go read up and ask for more information before suggesting that NSmen are not suitable to do specialized tasks. F35 repairs will never be done by NSmen. There is a system in place to allocate the suitability of NSmen to the specialized jobs. In addition, NSmen will always go through refreshers, update lessons and are allowed to query as and when, when in doubt.

    So if NSmen do not take up these specialized jobs in which they were trained, refreshed and updated regularly,who should take them up? What will be the impact?

    Why not think harder, maybe it’s the training for NSmen is insufficient? Why is it insufficient? Or is it a human error? T

    • Redwire Singapore

      January 29, 2019 at 2:24 pm

      Thanks for your comment. That is precisely the point – if machine repair was not a specialised job there wouldn’t be a vocation for “mechanics” for automobiles, what more war machines.

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

To Top