Tan Cheng Bock Whacks PAP’s 4th Gen Leaders: Insecure “Soldiers” Compared to LKY’s Old Guard

Dr Tan Cheng Bock had much criticism for the present-day PAP and its 4th Generation PAP at the Future of Singapore (FOSG) dialogue session yesterday (16 Dec).

Comparing the late Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew to his son, current Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, Dr Tan said that LKY would “never run from a fight”.

But, his son apparently prefers not to even engage, as seen in how Deputy Prime Minister first spoke on his behalf regarding the reserved elections debate in parliament, then how Minister in the PMO Chan Chun Sing spoke for DPM Teo, and how Law Minister K Shanmugam had to speak for Maj-Gen Chan.

He also took a swipe at the prime minister’s wife, Ho Ching, saying he opposed her appointment (as head of Temasek Holdings).

He said that the wife of the prime minister is an “important” position and must not be seen to have any conflict of interest, and history has shown that there have been such conflicts.

Dr Tan said that there is a sense of “insecurity” in the current PAP leadership.

He criticised the PAP’s 4th gen leaders for being  “soldiers” cut from the same mould and as such think and function alike.

Comparing them to the PAP old guard, Dr Tan said that the likes of Lim Kim San, Hon Sui Sen and Rajaratnam were a “very stable” group of leaders under the stewardship of LKY.

Dr Tan added that the Group Representation Scheme, which was formed with the intention of ensuring minority rights and a scheme that he had personally approved of, has since become a tool to coat-tail people into office.

Dr Tan said the PAP’s brand of politics has created “obedient” citizens whose lives are defined by “fear” and “insecurity”.

This, because of the pervasiveness of the government’s control, which causes them to consider their livelihoods when deciding on dissent.

He questioned, rhetorically:

“What kind of society will we have if fear defines our lives?”

A former PAP member of 26 years, Dr Tan said that some of his former PAP colleagues also share his views, but are afraid to voice their opinions.

Before a crowd-of about 200 people, some of which called for him to be a “unifying figure”, Dr Tan Cheng Bock revealed that he is planning to mentor what would hopefully be a new generation of political leaders.

“I want to be a mentor to teach people how to win elections”.

He said that he is willing to mentor “anybody who wants to learn”, whether they are from the PAP or the opposition.

“Quite a number have approached me to mentor them, and I will be meeting with them.”

With regards to contesting in the next General Election, Dr Tan said he is keeping his options open.




  1. Simon Lee

    December 18, 2017 at 7:03 pm

    Here is a Leader who stands on Higher Ground, has courage, is strong, authentic and does the truth-telling. There’s so much we can learn from him. Opposition members should tap on his expertise…be quick to sign up as mentees.

  2. Lawrence Yeo

    December 19, 2017 at 12:39 am

    Mr. Tan Cheng Bok is still leaking his wounds for not being a president. The way he acts will certainly not qualify him to be one. Don’t you all think so? He did not even dare wishper when LKY was around d and Ho Ching was then in Temasek. Why? because he was afraid to offend LKY and now mouse begin to play when the cat is not around. hee hee!! Look at his achievements and compare himself with the old PAP peers. He was underperforming compared with his peers and for that reason Tony Tan became a president and hr was put on the shelf.Has he fforgotten that eh??

  3. Lin Ah Shui

    December 19, 2017 at 5:34 pm

    Dr Tan. Don’t need to mentor. Form a new political party, like UMNO Baru, to replace the current PAP. Action please. Words can never do anything.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

To Top